So.. what u are saying, or rather Allah is saying, is that Animals have no means of deciding to do wrong, and therefore always do the right thing ?... they simply have no choice.

I would argue, that this would have been the perfect mechanism to equip humans with as well.. How much suffering, war and death could have been avoided with that ?... Not implimenting that in humans, literally has been a mistake of Biblical proportions...




But...

If animals cant do wrong.. they are pure good.. and there is indeed no need to have some sort of a judgment day. But that still doesn't explain to me, why the cant be admitted to heaven. Now it looks like they are punished for being good. Perhaps, it was a human, that thought of the saying:

"No good deed goes unpunished..." .. But an animal would know better...



You know what i believe in, Summer ?..

If you're good, you go to *heaven, and if you're bad.. you die when you die.."

*Heaven being a state of bliss, that is automatically created for you, by your own brain chemicals, on the moment of death. Indeed.. LSD to name one, is a chemical substance, (lysergic acid diethylamide) that triggers the exact same chemical in the brain when swallowed. I have used LSD, in a so called "paper trip" 3 times, back in 1975, to try to get answers to questions related to this. (And yes.. it worked..)

*note: Hash, or rather the chemical in the Cannabis Sativa plant, has a far less strong, but basically same effect.

So while the English have a saying; "the pleasure of the pudding is in the eating.." I would state; "the punishment, if deserved for mistakes while living... is in the dying.


As for the truth about life itself..:

We Homo sapiens originated around 200,000 BP (Before Present). The earliest humans were hunter-gatherers, a lifestyle well-suited to the savanna. They generally lived in small, nomadic groups. So... what were we different from animals, except for a higher IQ ?... Or do we have to conclude that people with an IQ lower then lets say; 60.. should from now on be referred to as Animals, and treated as such ?.... So no rights to go to heaven for them ?...

Being animals, they would automatically be more or less perfect.. so should we have to conclude from that, that intelligence is only bothering us ?...

Question 1 of interest:

Why is there no known record of any god, from before about 3000 Years BP ?.. While humans were around already for 387.000 years longer ?...

Question 2 of interest;

If A god.. only created us imperfect, so that we would make mistakes, solely for the purpose of having to ask the creator for forgiveness.. of mistakes, he could himself have easily avoided ?...

That sounds rather egoistic and self serving to me... tbh..